Skip to content
ADE Index

Perch vs Pi Herdsman vs Plannotator

Up to four tools, row by row. We do not guess: a cell we have not checked says so.

How they differ

Pick this if…

Paraphrased from each maker’s own description. Select a line for the quote.

Checked for Perch and Plannotator, not yet for Pi Herdsman: Price (Perch: ; Plannotator: )

Not yet checked for any of these tools: model providers, bring your own key, agents it runs, editors and systems.

Provider names use the same listing as each tool page. Dotted values open their quote. A capability not shown is not yet checked; the tool may still have it.

About these tools

Perch

Pi Herdsman

Plannotator

How to read the Index score

At a glance

Index score out of 100

Perch12Pi HerdsmanNot enough data yetPlannotator29

Mindshare HN mentions, 90 days

Perch2Pi Herdsman0Plannotator14

Adoption GitHub stars, not scored

Perch31Pi Herdsman236PlannotatorNot yet checked

Release days last 90 days

Perch18Pi Herdsman56Plannotator58

Votes can only raise a score: up to 20% of it reflects upvotes, graded on a curve against the most-voted tool. The square-root curve has a floor of 100 effective votes. Votes decay with a 90-day half-life. Maker self-votes do not count. Counts below 10 are hidden for display only. After activation, the score is 80% mindshare plus 20% of the greater of mindshare and the vote score. GitHub stars do not affect the Index score. Mindshare uses a log scale; votes use the square-root curve and a 100-vote floor. Ranks use unrounded scores. Mindshare and adoption bars are log-scaled; the others are linear within this comparison. How the score is built

Differences only
3 of 4
PerchAgent add-on
Pi Herdsmanboadij · Agent add-on
PlannotatorAgent add-on
Interface
What it is
Mac companion for answering coding-agent prompts and returning to sessions
Pi fleet orchestration with nested delegation and background work in Herdr
Review interface for agent plans, artifacts, code diffs and pull requests
Category
Agent add-on
Agent add-on
Agent add-on
Pricing
Starts at (billing shown)
Not yet checked
Lowest monthly plan
Not yet checked
Not yet checked
Not yet checked
Free tier
Not yet checked
Plans
Not yet checked
Bring your own key
Not yet checked
Not yet checked
Not yet checked
Models and agents
Model providers
Not yet checkedSource
Not yet checked
Not yet checked
Models
Not yet checked
Not yet checked
Not yet checked
Drives these agents
Not yet checked
Not yet checked
Not yet checked
Source and activity
Source
GitHub stars
Most
Not yet checked
Release days, last 90 days
18
56
58Most
Release days per week
Latest release, any channel
v0.5.6 16 Nov 2026
v0.51.0 18 Nov 2026
v0.29.0 18 Nov 2026
Index score
Score and rank
12 #107 Score 11.9; ranked on the unrounded score
Not enough data yet
29 #39 Score 29.4; ranked on the unrounded score
Mindshare
122 Hacker News mentions in the last 90 days
00 Hacker News mentions in the last 90 days
2914 Hacker News mentions in the last 90 days
Adoption, not scored
2831 stars, read 17 Nov 2026
45236 stars, read 17 Nov 2026
Not yet checked
Votes
—Votes can only raise a score: up to 20% of it reflects upvotes, graded on a curve against the most-voted tool. The square-root curve has a floor of 100 effective votes. Votes decay with a 90-day half-life. Maker self-votes do not count. Counts below 10 are hidden for display only.
—Votes can only raise a score: up to 20% of it reflects upvotes, graded on a curve against the most-voted tool. The square-root curve has a floor of 100 effective votes. Votes decay with a 90-day half-life. Maker self-votes do not count. Counts below 10 are hidden for display only.
—Votes can only raise a score: up to 20% of it reflects upvotes, graded on a curve against the most-voted tool. The square-root curve has a floor of 100 effective votes. Votes decay with a 90-day half-life. Maker self-votes do not count. Counts below 10 are hidden for display only.
Rank history
First ranked 18 Nov 2026
Not ranked
First ranked 18 Nov 2026
Full page

Watch Perch vs Pi Herdsman vs Plannotator on YouTube

More comparisons

Build your own