Skip to content
ADE Index

Aider vs Pi vs smelt

Up to four tools, row by row. We do not guess: a cell we have not checked says so.

How they differ

SystemsAider 1 · Pi 4 · smelt 3
, , ,
, ,
Pick this if…

Paraphrased from each maker’s own description. Select a line for the quote.

Same for all 3 (1): Price: Free (open source)
  • Price: Free (open source) · ·

Not yet checked for any of these tools: agents it runs.

Dotted values open their quote.

What each can do

Select an answer to see the maker’s sentence, or what we searched.

We have not checked smelt’s capabilities yet. 17 capabilities are checked for at least two of these tools. 4 get different answers, among them Plan mode, Undo file edits and Notifications; on 2 more a maker’s docs say nothing; 6 differ only in a limit. 12 others are checked for one tool only.

Differences only10
  • Yesthe maker documents it
  • With add-onAdd-onsomething the maker publishes that you install or run
  • No, per makerNothe maker says it does not
  • Not in the maker’s docsNot foundwe searched the maker’s docs and found nothing; not a “no”
  • *its limit or add-on is named under the row
  • Emptynot yet checked
  • From the listingthe listing’s own facts; not one of the capabilities we check
Capability

Models, keys and usage

Bring your own keyFrom the listing
Named model providersFrom the listing
,,,,,,,,
+5 more model providers
,,,,
Not every provider checked yet
,,,,,,,,
+28 more model providers
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
,,,,,,,,
+1 more model providers
+ providers you add
Listing also names: Moonshot AI
Local modelsNot yet checked: smelt
Not yet checked for smelt
Custom OpenAI-compatible endpointNot yet checked: smelt
Not yet checked for smelt
Token and cost usageNot yet checked: smelt
Not yet checked for smelt

MCP, hooks, skills and subagents

MCP serversNot yet checked: smelt
local and remote
Not yet checked for smelt
HooksNot yet checked: smelt
Lint/test commands after each edit
Not yet checked for smelt
SkillsNot yet checked: Aider, smelt
Not yet checked for Aider
Not yet checked for smelt
SubagentsNot yet checked: smelt
Not built in; Subagent example
Not yet checked for smelt
PluginsNot yet checked: Aider, smelt
Not yet checked for Aider
Not yet checked for smelt
Custom commandsNot yet checked: smelt
Not yet checked for smelt

Editors, scripts and CI

Editor integrationNot yet checked: Pi, smelt
Terminal plus --watch-files
Not yet checked for Pi
Not yet checked for smelt
Headless modeNot yet checked: smelt
Not yet checked for smelt
JSON outputNot yet checked: Aider, smelt
Not yet checked for Aider
Not yet checked for smelt
Commit attribution controlNot yet checked: Pi, smelt
Not yet checked for Pi
Not yet checked for smelt

Review, steer and undo

Plan modeNot yet checked: smelt
Ask mode, then code mode
Not built in; Plan Mode example
Not yet checked for smelt
Read-only modeNot yet checked: smelt
Not built in; Plan Mode example
Not yet checked for smelt
Review diffsNot yet checked: Pi, smelt
Not yet checked for Pi
Not yet checked for smelt
Undo file editsNot yet checked: smelt
Maker's git-checkpoint example
Not yet checked for smelt

Parallel agents

Git worktreesNot yet checked: Pi, smelt
Not yet checked for Pi
Not yet checked for smelt

Context and memory

Project instruction filesNot yet checked: smelt
A conventions file you configure
Not yet checked for smelt
Resume a sessionNot yet checked: smelt
Opt-in flag
Not yet checked for smelt
Browse past sessionsNot yet checked: Aider, smelt
Not yet checked for Aider
Not yet checked for smelt

Remote and mobile control

NotificationsNot yet checked: smelt
Off by default
Maker's notify example
Not yet checked for smelt

Sandbox, permissions and privacy

OS-level sandboxNot yet checked: Aider, smelt
Not yet checked for Aider
Gondolin micro-VM example
Not yet checked for smelt
Approval modesNot yet checked: Aider, smelt
Not yet checked for Aider
Not yet checked for smelt
Runs in a containerNot yet checked: smelt
Official Docker images
The repo's Docker recipe
Not yet checked for smelt
Telemetry opt-outNot yet checked: smelt
With --analytics-disable
Not yet checked for smelt

Images, web and your computer

Image inputNot yet checked: smelt
Needs a compatible terminal
Not yet checked for smelt
Fetch URLsNot yet checked: Pi, smelt
Not yet checked for Pi
Not yet checked for smelt
Voice inputNot yet checked: Pi, smelt
Not yet checked for Pi
Not yet checked for smelt
Not yet checked: , ,

8 capabilities are not yet checked for any of these tools and are not shown. Each answer is about the CLI agent in its column. Something the maker publishes separately, such as an editor plugin or a GitHub Action, shows as “With add-on”, even when it has its own listing here. How capabilities are checked

About these tools

Aider

Pi

smelt

How to read the Index score

At a glance

Index score out of 100

Aider42Pi78smelt12

Mindshare HN mentions, 90 days

Aider47Pi1,310smelt2

Adoption GitHub stars, not scored

Aider50.2kPi123ksmelt73

Release days last 90 days

Aider0Pi19smelt9

Platforms systems and surfaces

Aider1Pi4smelt3

Votes can only raise a score: up to 20% of it reflects upvotes, graded on a curve against the most-voted tool. The square-root curve has a floor of 100 effective votes. Votes decay with a 90-day half-life. Maker self-votes do not count. Counts below 10 are hidden for display only. After activation, the score is 80% mindshare plus 20% of the greater of mindshare and the vote score. GitHub stars do not affect the Index score. Mindshare uses a log scale; votes use the square-root curve and a 100-vote floor. Ranks use unrounded scores. Mindshare and adoption bars are log-scaled; the others are linear within this comparison. How the score is built

Differences only
3 of 4
AiderAider AI · CLI agent
PiEarendil Works · CLI agent
smeltleonardcser · CLI agent
Interface
Terminal chat: a prompt, a search/replace edit block for hello.py, then an auto-commit
pi startup listing loaded context, skills and extensions, then reading docs and running bash
What it is
Pair program with LLMs to start a new project or build on your existing codebase
Minimal, extensible agent harness that you can make your own
A fast, Lua-scriptable coding agent for the terminal
Category
CLI agent
CLI agent
CLI agent
Pricing
Starts at (billing shown)
Lowest monthly plan
Not yet checked
Not yet checked
Not yet checked
Free tier
Plans
Runs on
Linux
Not yet checked
Yes
Yes
Terminal
Yes
Yes
Not yet checked
Windows
Not yet checked
Yes
Yes
macOS
Not yet checked
Yes
Yes
Models and agents
Drives these agents
Not yet checked
Not yet checked
Not yet checked
Source and activity
Source
GitHub stars
Most
Release days, last 90 days
0
19Most
9
Release days per week
None in 26 weeks
Latest release, any channel
v0.86.0 9 Aug 2025
v1.5.2 10 Nov 2026
v0.8.1 18 Nov 2026
Index score
Score and rank
42 #22 Score 42.0; ranked on the unrounded score
78 #4 Score 77.9; ranked on the unrounded score
12 #107 Score 11.9; ranked on the unrounded score
Mindshare
4247 Hacker News mentions in the last 90 days
781,310 Hacker News mentions in the last 90 days
122 Hacker News mentions in the last 90 days
Adoption, not scored
8950,162 stars, read 18 Nov 2026
96122,575 stars, read 18 Nov 2026
3573 stars, read 18 Nov 2026
Votes
—Votes can only raise a score: up to 20% of it reflects upvotes, graded on a curve against the most-voted tool. The square-root curve has a floor of 100 effective votes. Votes decay with a 90-day half-life. Maker self-votes do not count. Counts below 10 are hidden for display only.
—Votes can only raise a score: up to 20% of it reflects upvotes, graded on a curve against the most-voted tool. The square-root curve has a floor of 100 effective votes. Votes decay with a 90-day half-life. Maker self-votes do not count. Counts below 10 are hidden for display only.
—Votes can only raise a score: up to 20% of it reflects upvotes, graded on a curve against the most-voted tool. The square-root curve has a floor of 100 effective votes. Votes decay with a 90-day half-life. Maker self-votes do not count. Counts below 10 are hidden for display only.
Rank history
First ranked 18 Nov 2026
First ranked 18 Nov 2026
First ranked 18 Nov 2026
Full page

Watch Aider vs Pi vs smelt on YouTube

More comparisons

Build your own